Under $500

Consumer's Choice Pillows

Loved by shoppers like you — these are the pillows our customers reach for again and again. Crowd-tested favorites that pair lasting quality with prices worth celebrating. Find your perfect match below!

$59.99

$59.99 - $59.99

$59.99

$39.99

$39.99 - $39.99

$39.99

Meiling Pillow

Bring an effortlessly cool and contemporary feeling to a space with this toss pillow. A hint of metallic sheen takes its neutral palette to a new l...

View full details

$59.99

$59.99 - $59.99

$59.99

$39.99

$39.99 - $39.99

$39.99

Save $20.00

$99.99 - $279.99

$99.99

$69.99 - $209.99

$69.99

Aavie Pillow

Bring textural interest to your decor with the visual intrigue of this pillow. Its luxuriously looped design is utterly charming, adding a relaxed ...

View full details

$99.99 - $279.99

$99.99

$69.99 - $209.99

$69.99

Save up to $70.00

Under $500 — Frequently Asked Questions

What under $500 brands does Theo's Factory Direct Mattress & Furniture (Columbus, OH) carry?

Our Under $500 selection includes Ashley Furniture, Coaster Z2 Premium, chosen for a balance of quality, comfort, and value. Browse the collection to compare styles and finishes side by side.

How do I choose the right under $500?

Measure where the under $500 will go, then check your doorways, hallways, and stairwells to be sure it will fit inside. Think about how it will be used and by whom — homes with kids or pets do best with durable, easy-clean materials — and match the color, finish, and scale to what you already own. Want a second opinion? Just contact us.

Do you deliver under $500 items?

Yes. We deliver throughout our local service area and, in most cases, will bring your under $500 inside and place it where you want it. See our shipping & delivery policy for timelines, or contact us for a quote and an estimated delivery window.

Can I finance a under $500?

Yes. We offer financing options on qualifying purchases, often with promotional low- or no-interest plans. Ask us about prequalifying so you can shop with a budget in mind.

Does my under $500 come with a warranty?

Most pieces are covered by the manufacturer's warranty, which typically protects against defects in materials and workmanship for a period that varies by brand and product. Keep your order confirmation as proof of purchase, and contact us if you ever need to file a claim — we'll help you work with the manufacturer.

What if my under $500 arrives damaged?

Inspect it at delivery, and if anything isn't right, note it on the paperwork, snap a few photos, and contact us immediately. We'll coordinate a repair, replacement part, or return under our return policy.

Consumer's Choice Pillows

Under $500

Filters

Filter

Refine

Brand

Type

Price

AR Availability

Bed Size

Color

Consumer Assembly

Group

Material

Piece Count

Product Theme

Product Video

Rug Special Feature

Seat Count

Shade

Shape

Shipping

Style

Sub Brand

Throw Fabric

Top Products

Under $500 — Frequently Asked Questions

What under $500 brands does Theo's Factory Direct Mattress & Furniture (Columbus, OH) carry?

How do I choose the right under $500?

Do you deliver under $500 items?

Can I finance a under $500?

Does my under $500 come with a warranty?

What if my under $500 arrives damaged?